The Canadian Criminal (In)Justice System: A Case Study Of Systemic Racism And Sexism In A Criminal Trial For The Death Of An Indigenous Woman
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
The social positions and living conditions of Indigenous peoples, particularly Indigenous women living in what is currently known as Canada, are now a significant concern among communities, academics, politicians, policymakers, and the public, after having long been personal and political concerns for Indigenous peoples. Indigenous women’s social and living conditions, especially the disproportionate rates at which many are Survivors of violence and victims of violence, have become a significant focus of public attention following the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (NIMMIWG), officially launched in 2016 (official launch) and with the final report published in June 2019 (NIMMIWG, 2019). The final report documents how the failure of the state to investigate the murder and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls constitutes genocide (NIMMIWG, 2019, p. 6). The Prime Minister of Canada finally acknowledged in a speech in 2019 that “we accept the finding that this was genocide, and we will move forward to end this ongoing national tragedy” (The Globe and Mail, 2019).
Despite this recent state recognition of the magnitude of the violence against Indigenous women and girls and prior mobilization by these women’s families and nations, additional international, national, and local attention is needed to understand the way that the criminal courts treat Indigenous women who engage in sex work and who are victims of fatal violence. Through the lens of Indigenous feminisms, this research is guided by the following research question: Do systemic racism and sexism exist and operate in a criminal trial involving an Indigenous woman who engaged in sex work and a White man alleged to have committed the violent act (her murder)? To approach this question, this research explores the words used in court actors’ oral arguments to refer to the Indigenous victim, which may reproduce deep-seated systemic racism and sexism. This study investigates whether the failure of court actors to challenge racism and sexism contributes to a history of victim-blaming and reinforces the idea that Indigenous women are sexually available and deserving of violence. This study also explores whether the criminal courts ignore, partially recognize, or fully recognize histories of residential schools and intergenerational trauma, poverty and homelessness, and the connection between sex work and victimization. Relying on both content and thematic analysis, this study explicitly analyzes the court transcripts of the oral arguments for the 2015 case R. v. Barton, involving an Indigenous woman engaged in sex work and who died as a result of violence (Cindy Gladue) and a White man alleged to have committed the act of violence that led to her death (Bradley Barton). This research concludes with recommendations to address the inaccurate representations of Indigenous women, specifically those engaged in sex work, in the criminal courts so that the criminal justice system may address the systemic genocidal violence against Indigenous women and communities.