Self-Regulated Executive Functions in Academic Achievement
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This study sought to determine whether students! academic achievement can be predicted from their ratings of their own self-regulated executive functions. A new self-report questionnaire, the Self-Regulated Executive Functions Inventory (SREFD) was designed for this purpose. It consists of 84 items across seven subscales: Working Memory, Initiative, Monitoring, Planning, Goal-Setting, Self-Control, and Time Management. Statistical analysis of students’ responses on the SREFI revealed a high degree of inter-item agreement, moderate to high interscale correlations, and moderate correlations with most scales of the Behaviour Rating Inventory of Executive Functioning — Parent form. It also compared favourably with scores on the Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System.
A total of 172 students (M age = 11:9; SD = .81) from two large public middle schools in suburban Toronto participated in the research. The SREFI scales differentiated students with above-average marks from those with average and low-average marks. Students with marks above 80% reported significantly better self-regulation than the other students. There was a great deal of variability in reports of self-regulation among students with average and below-average marks (marks in the 60 to 80% range). Interestingly, students with marks below 60% did not report many difficulties with self-regulation.
There was a significant interaction between scores on the SREFI and IQ, as measured by the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence. Underachieving students with high IQs reported having the most problems with self-regulated executive functions compared to other students, and overachieving students with above- and below-average IQs reported the least problems with self-regulated executive functions. These results are discussed in relation to the models of selfregulation described by Veenman (1993).
The Time Management scale of the SREFI was the most significant factor in the prediction of academic achievement. Time Management had the highest correlations with IQ and the Homework Completion teacher-rated learning skill.
Several models proposing an interactive role of executive self-regulation, affective variables, and skills in academic performance (Ellis & Zimmerman, 2001; Hartman & Sternberg, 1993; Weinstein, Husman & Dierking, 2000) were also tested. The present study confirmed the hypothesis that students with higher levels of self-regulation, as measured by the SREFI, had fewer personality problems and were generally more positive emotionally, as measured by the Achievement and Motivation Profile — Junior (Mandel, 1995), relative to students with lower levels of self-regulation. The results suggested that affective components play a higher role during the second, Performance, phase of self-regulation than during the first, Forethought, phase (Ellis & Zimmerman, 2001). There were low to moderate correlations between teacher ratings of most student learning skills and student ratings of executive self-regulation.
The results suggest that achievers and overachievers with high intelligence may benefit from learning how to transfer and engage their knowledge of self-regulation to their academic performance. In contrast, students of far below average intelligence should first increase their metacognition: they should learn to recognize the different elements of self-regulation and develop insight into their own skills in this area.