Active Inhibition in a Mental Attention Reversal - Shift Task
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Central to the understanding of the development of cognitive processing is the exploration and elucidation of the mechanisms involved in inhibition and interference. This study investigated whether there are differences in the development of active inhibition and interference. The negative priming (NP) paradigm, the delay in response to previously irrelevant stimuli, was used to test inhibition. The reversal shift (RS) paradigm, the delay in response due to the shifting of the relevant colour, was used to test interference. Twenty children in each of grades 2, 4, and 6 were tested with the computer based Mental-Attention Reversal Shift (MARS), task designed for the present study. In the MARS task the subjects were asked to respond by pressing keyboard buttons corresponding relevant animal shapes presented, along with distractors, on a computer screen. Relevance was determined by animal colour (red or blue) which had to match the colour of a “wand” displayed at the top of the screen. The number of relevant animal shapes (item class) varied randomly from one to four, and they were located randomly among the same number of animals in the irrelevant colour and letters of the English alphabet. The total number of shapes in any one testing trial of the MARS task was 26, and the total number of red shapes was equal to the number of blue shapes. All shapes were randomly located in an invisible circle in the center of the screen. Analysis of time of first keypress indicated that there were significant delays in the negative priming (NP) and reversal shift (RS) displays relative to the control condition; responses in RS displays were slower than in NP. Children were less accurate in RS, but not in NP, compared with the control condition. Overall grade 2 children were slower to respond, but not less accurate, than were the older children. A mixed models analysis indicated that negative priming delays were restricted to class 4 items. In contrast, grade 4 and 6 children showed delay in RS among all item classes. Younger children (grade 2) showed RS delay in responses only in item class 3. On the basis of these results it was concluded that inhibition and interference are different mechanisms of interruption.