Gilbert, LietteMartino, David2026-11-052026-11-052026-08-31Major Paper, Master of Environmental Studies, Faculty of Environmental and Urban Change, York Universityhttps://hdl.handle.net/10315/44131In the contemporary age, multi-modal transit hubs (MTHs) have assumed a prominent role within urban and regional landscapes. Moving hundreds of thousands of people each day to and from their destinations, these hubs exist as both sites of mobility and manifestations of public life, whereby the praxis of movement and the free exchange of ideas can occur. However, as cities increasingly pursue sustainable mobility strategies, the redevelopment of these infrastructures through large-scale megaprojects has introduced new pressures that complicate their role and meaning within society. Partly driven by these initiatives’ close alignment with the private sector, understanding this underresearched dynamic can help identify how MTHs currently function as inclusive public environments, or lack thereof. The main objective of this research was to explore how users experience the conditions created through megaproject redevelopment, focusing specifically on Toronto’s Union Station and the Union Station Revitalization Project (USRP). By triangulating data from direct observations, policy document reviews, and semi-structured interviews, this paper evaluates how the USRP altered the civicness of the station and consequently, created tensions between its original vision, commercial objectives, and the lived experiences of those who use the space. These findings demonstrate that the perceived success of the USRP varies considerably according to user type and patterns of interaction with the four spatial realms identified in this paper. It also points out the need for planning approaches that protect civic spaces from the private realm and that continue to center diverse user experiences.enMulti-modal transit hubsCivic spaceTransit megaprojectsSpatial controlCommercializationThe Cost of Civic Space: Toronto’s Union Station and the Politics of Transit MegaprojectsResearch Paper